Stallman: ‘OpenBSD Ports Suggests Non-Free Software’

Richard Stallman sent a message to OpenBSD-Misc, explaining why he doesn’t recommend OpenBSD. “From what I have heard, OpenBSD does not contain non-free software (though I am not sure whether it contains any non-free firmware blobs). However, its ports system does suggest non-free programs, or at least so I was told when I looked for some BSD variant that I could recommend. I therefore exercise my freedom of speech by not including OpenBSD in the list of systems that I recommend to the public.” His mail started a huge thread (that’s just page 1) and since then he’s under a blast of messages from Theo de Raadt and the OpenBSD users. De Raadt replied: “Richard, you are wrong. You said very clearly in your interview that the ports tree contains non-free software. It does not. It is just a scaffold of Makefiles containing URLs, and an occasional patch here or there. You are just plain wrong. And you are not enough of a man to admit that you are wrong. I may be unfriendly at times, but you are a power-misusing hypocritical liar who attacks projects that try harder than any others to only make free software available. Shame on you.”

264 Comments

  1. 2007-12-17 4:55 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:12 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:59 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:18 pm
    • 2007-12-17 6:02 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:11 pm
        • 2007-12-17 6:13 pm
          • 2007-12-17 8:24 pm
          • 2007-12-17 8:47 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:28 pm
        • 2007-12-17 6:27 pm
        • 2007-12-17 7:38 pm
          • 2007-12-18 3:03 am
          • 2007-12-18 4:03 am
  2. 2007-12-17 4:57 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:32 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:23 pm
    • 2007-12-17 8:13 pm
  3. 2007-12-17 5:06 pm
  4. 2007-12-17 5:08 pm
    • 2007-12-17 7:02 pm
    • 2007-12-17 7:14 pm
    • 2007-12-18 7:08 am
  5. 2007-12-17 5:10 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:24 pm
      • 2007-12-17 7:02 pm
        • 2007-12-17 7:12 pm
          • 2007-12-17 8:35 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:05 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:34 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:38 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:46 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:46 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:59 pm
          • 2007-12-17 11:03 pm
          • 2007-12-18 12:43 am
          • 2007-12-18 1:02 am
          • 2007-12-18 12:07 am
      • 2007-12-18 1:31 pm
        • 2007-12-18 3:47 pm
          • 2007-12-19 8:58 am
    • 2007-12-17 7:09 pm
      • 2007-12-17 7:43 pm
        • 2007-12-18 9:01 am
    • 2007-12-17 10:34 pm
  6. 2007-12-17 5:13 pm
  7. 2007-12-17 5:14 pm
  8. 2007-12-17 5:16 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:24 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:30 pm
      • 2007-12-17 5:38 pm
        • 2007-12-17 7:21 pm
          • 2007-12-17 7:28 pm
          • 2007-12-17 8:32 pm
          • 2007-12-18 8:53 am
      • 2007-12-17 6:18 pm
        • 2007-12-17 7:22 pm
          • 2007-12-17 8:09 pm
          • 2007-12-17 8:45 pm
          • 2007-12-17 9:20 pm
          • 2007-12-17 9:28 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:42 pm
          • 2007-12-18 6:53 am
          • 2007-12-19 6:00 am
      • 2007-12-18 12:39 am
        • 2007-12-18 12:49 am
          • 2007-12-18 1:38 pm
        • 2007-12-18 12:55 am
          • 2007-12-18 7:23 am
      • 2007-12-18 2:40 am
      • 2007-12-18 7:22 am
    • 2007-12-17 5:37 pm
    • 2007-12-17 6:07 pm
      • 2007-12-17 10:54 pm
      • 2007-12-17 11:07 pm
      • 2007-12-18 7:14 am
    • 2007-12-17 7:58 pm
      • 2007-12-17 10:43 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:02 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:02 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:33 pm
    • 2007-12-18 7:52 am
      • 2007-12-18 1:25 pm
        • 2007-12-19 9:45 am
    • 2007-12-18 5:25 pm
    • 2007-12-19 2:07 pm
  9. 2007-12-17 5:21 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:41 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:38 pm
        • 2007-12-17 7:04 pm
  10. 2007-12-17 5:26 pm
    • 2007-12-17 6:36 pm
    • 2007-12-17 7:58 pm
      • 2007-12-18 4:01 am
    • 2007-12-18 7:17 am
      • 2007-12-18 7:15 pm
        • 2007-12-19 5:53 pm
          • 2007-12-19 6:05 pm
          • 2007-12-20 9:10 am
          • 2007-12-19 7:11 pm
          • 2007-12-20 8:54 am
          • 2007-12-20 8:36 pm
          • 2007-12-21 6:07 pm
          • 2007-12-21 7:07 pm
    • 2007-12-18 1:35 pm
    • 2007-12-18 11:20 pm
    • 2007-12-19 7:13 am
  11. 2007-12-17 5:26 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:41 pm
    • 2007-12-17 5:43 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:11 pm
        • 2007-12-17 6:20 pm
          • 2007-12-17 7:02 pm
          • 2007-12-17 7:14 pm
          • 2007-12-17 9:29 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:15 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:22 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:35 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:43 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:59 pm
          • 2007-12-17 11:26 pm
          • 2007-12-18 12:57 am
          • 2007-12-17 10:55 pm
          • 2007-12-19 7:29 am
          • 2007-12-19 7:36 am
        • 2007-12-17 10:02 pm
  12. 2007-12-17 6:19 pm
    • 2007-12-17 6:32 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:45 pm
        • 2007-12-17 6:49 pm
          • 2007-12-17 6:58 pm
          • 2007-12-17 7:06 pm
          • 2007-12-17 7:20 pm
          • 2007-12-17 9:42 pm
          • 2007-12-17 10:30 pm
          • 2007-12-18 12:52 am
          • 2007-12-18 7:35 pm
          • 2007-12-17 11:56 pm
          • 2007-12-17 11:23 pm
          • 2007-12-18 1:00 am
          • 2007-12-18 1:13 am
          • 2007-12-18 1:29 am
          • 2007-12-18 1:53 am
          • 2007-12-18 7:55 am
          • 2007-12-19 7:37 pm
          • 2007-12-19 11:41 pm
          • 2007-12-20 4:27 am
          • 2007-12-20 4:33 am
          • 2007-12-20 9:20 am
          • 2007-12-19 6:48 pm
      • 2007-12-17 6:47 pm
    • 2007-12-17 6:59 pm
  13. 2007-12-17 6:23 pm
  14. 2007-12-17 6:26 pm
    • 2007-12-18 1:18 am
  15. 2007-12-17 6:28 pm
    • 2007-12-18 2:20 am
      • 2007-12-18 2:33 am
        • 2007-12-18 2:58 am
        • 2007-12-18 7:57 am
      • 2007-12-18 2:24 pm
  16. 2007-12-17 6:33 pm
  17. 2007-12-17 6:34 pm
  18. 2007-12-17 6:39 pm
  19. 2007-12-17 6:58 pm
    • 2007-12-17 8:48 pm
  20. 2007-12-17 7:22 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:08 pm
  21. 2007-12-17 7:26 pm
  22. 2007-12-17 8:05 pm
  23. 2007-12-17 8:06 pm
    • 2007-12-17 8:18 pm
    • 2007-12-17 11:44 pm
  24. 2007-12-17 8:13 pm
  25. 2007-12-17 8:28 pm
  26. 2007-12-17 8:30 pm
    • 2007-12-17 9:26 pm
      • 2007-12-17 11:39 pm
  27. 2007-12-17 8:33 pm
    • 2007-12-17 9:03 pm
  28. 2007-12-17 8:43 pm
    • 2007-12-17 8:57 pm
      • 2007-12-17 9:31 pm
    • 2007-12-17 9:24 pm
  29. 2007-12-17 9:06 pm
  30. 2007-12-17 9:12 pm
    • 2007-12-17 9:25 pm
    • 2007-12-18 8:02 am
      • 2007-12-18 1:28 pm
      • 2007-12-18 3:19 pm
        • 2007-12-18 5:55 pm
          • 2007-12-18 6:33 pm
  31. 2007-12-17 9:30 pm
    • 2007-12-17 9:55 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:16 pm
  32. 2007-12-17 9:44 pm
    • 2007-12-17 9:59 pm
      • 2007-12-17 11:08 pm
  33. 2007-12-17 10:08 pm
  34. 2007-12-17 10:16 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:40 pm
      • 2007-12-18 8:04 am
        • 2007-12-19 12:28 am
          • 2007-12-19 2:17 am
  35. 2007-12-17 10:53 pm
    • 2007-12-17 10:57 pm
      • 2007-12-18 12:41 am
        • 2007-12-18 12:59 am
    • 2007-12-17 11:06 pm
    • 2007-12-17 11:09 pm
  36. 2007-12-17 11:28 pm
  37. 2007-12-17 11:30 pm
    • 2007-12-17 11:42 pm
      • 2007-12-17 11:50 pm
      • 2007-12-18 12:25 am
        • 2007-12-18 12:39 am
          • 2007-12-18 3:33 pm
          • 2007-12-18 4:43 pm
          • 2007-12-18 8:27 pm
        • 2007-12-18 12:48 am
    • 2007-12-17 11:47 pm
      • 2007-12-18 7:46 am
  38. 2007-12-17 11:48 pm
    • 2007-12-18 7:44 am
  39. 2007-12-18 2:20 am
  40. 2007-12-18 3:30 am
  41. 2007-12-18 4:33 am
  42. 2007-12-18 7:42 am
    • 2007-12-18 7:51 am
      • 2007-12-18 8:11 am
        • 2007-12-18 7:18 pm
    • 2007-12-18 9:12 am
  43. 2007-12-18 9:05 am
  44. 2007-12-18 9:14 am
  45. 2007-12-18 10:22 am
    • 2007-12-18 12:58 pm
      • 2007-12-18 9:04 pm
  46. 2007-12-18 12:24 pm
    • 2007-12-18 3:25 pm
      • 2007-12-19 9:53 am
        • 2007-12-19 10:49 am
          • 2007-12-19 11:03 am
          • 2007-12-19 11:08 am
          • 2007-12-19 11:15 am
          • 2007-12-19 7:48 pm
          • 2007-12-19 8:52 pm
    • 2007-12-19 7:12 am
  47. 2007-12-18 3:50 pm
  48. 2007-12-19 12:19 pm
    • 2007-12-19 2:16 pm
  49. 2007-12-19 6:47 pm
    • 2007-12-19 7:14 pm
      • 2007-12-19 7:22 pm
        • 2007-12-19 8:38 pm
          • 2007-12-19 9:04 pm
          • 2007-12-19 11:06 pm
          • 2007-12-20 1:44 am
          • 2007-12-20 4:22 am
          • 2007-12-20 4:07 pm
          • 2007-12-20 8:42 pm
    • 2007-12-19 7:24 pm
  50. 2007-12-19 9:11 pm
  51. 2007-12-21 7:26 pm